咨询律师 找律师 案件委托   热门省份: 北京 浙江 上海 山东 广东 天津 重庆 江苏 湖南 湖北 四川 河南 河北 110法律咨询网 法律咨询 律师在线
当前位置: 首页 > 法律论文 > 刑事诉讼法论文 >
论刑事附带民事诉讼精神损害赔偿制度确立
www.110.com 2010-07-24 14:02

摘 要:
长期以来,刑事附带民事诉讼是否允许被害人向被告人提出精神损害赔偿请求问题,在法学理论界存在较大的争议,现行法律体系中民事实体法规定了精神赔偿,而刑事诉讼法又否定了精神赔偿。司法实践中存在民事实体法与刑事程序法的矛盾,适用出现不平等,不利于当事人在诉讼活动中得到公平的待遇,损害了司法公正,也有违立法的初衷。因此,笔者认为应当确立刑事附带民事诉讼精神损害赔偿制度。从我国刑事附带民事诉讼精神损害赔偿制度的现状出发,分析了立法规定、司法实践中存在的冲突和弊端,合理借鉴英美法和大陆法两大法系的相关法律,进一步探讨了阻却我国刑事附带民事诉讼精神损害赔偿确立的现行法律观点,并提出了确立我国刑事附带民事诉讼精神损害赔偿制度的法律依据。

 

关键词:
刑事诉讼 附带民事诉讼 精神损害赔偿


Research of Compensation of Criminal Mental Damage

Abstract: Since long ago, whether does the criminal supplementary civil action allow the victim to the accused person to propose the spirit damage compensate request question, in a legal science theory existence greater dispute, in the present legal framework the civil substantive law has stipulated the spiritual compensation, but Law of Criminal Procedure also denied the spiritual compensation. In the judicial practice has the civil substantive law and the criminal procedural law contradiction, is suitable appears not equally, is disadvantageous obtains the fair treatment to the litigant in the lawsuit activity, harmed the judicature to be fair, also had disobeys the legislation the original intention. Therefore, the author thought must establish the criminal supplementary civil action spirit damage compensates system. Embarked from our country criminal activity supplementary civil action spirit damage compensate system present situation, has analyzed the conflict and the malpractice which in the legislation stipulation, the judicial practice existed, reasonably profited from the English America method and the continental method two big legal systems related laws, further has discussed the anti- actually our country criminal activity supplementary civil action spirit damage compensate establishment present point of law, and proposed established our country criminal activity supplementary civil action spirit damage compensate system the legal basis.

发布免费法律咨询
广告服务 | 联系方式 | 人才招聘 | 友情链接网站地图
copyright©2006 - 2010 110.com inc. all rights reserved.
版权所有:110.com 京icp备06054339